Monmouth University 2027 Recruiting: CAA QB 22 Miles From Campus — Evan Colon

Sometimes the best recruit is the one closest to home. For Monmouth University, that player is Evan Colon — a 2027 dual-threat quarterback from Rutherford, New Jersey, who attends St. Mary's High School just 22 miles from Monmouth's West Long Branch campus.

Colon has emerged as one of the more intriguing signal-callers in the Garden State's loaded 2027 class. Despite limited exposure coming off a shortened junior season (7 games due to a preseason injury), he posted 1,077 passing yards, 483 rushing yards, and 14 total touchdowns — numbers that project to elite productivity over a full 10-game slate.

Why Monmouth Should Be Calling

The Monmouth Hawks run a tempo-based spread offense that demands mobile, high-IQ quarterbacks who can process quickly and extend plays with their legs. Colon is a textbook fit. Standing 6'0" and 175 lbs, he's a prototypical CAA-level passer who can grow into a Big South or Coastal Athletic Association starter within two years.

His 3.5 GPA indicates he can handle the academic demands of a D-I program. His dual-threat ability — nearly 500 rushing yards as a passer in half a season — mirrors the profile Monmouth has successfully developed in the past. He's also within driving distance for family visits, which reduces recruiting risk significantly.

The Opportunity Is Right Now

Colon currently holds no Division I offers, which means the window to get in early is wide open. Programs that identify prospects before the national services do tend to build stronger relationships and land commitments at a fraction of the cost (recruiting resources, official visits, etc.).

For a program like Monmouth that competes in the CAA and scouts the northeast heavily, passing on a 2027 QB from your own backyard — one with measurables, production, and academic standing — would be a rare miss. The film is available. The numbers check out. The proximity is unmatched.

What the Data Says

Our AI scouting model has Colon rated as a 4-star (AI-projected) prospect with an 87/100 composite score, placing him in the 83rd national percentile and 91st in New Jersey. For context, those are mid-major starter numbers with Power Four upside if he adds weight and refines pocket presence through his senior season.

The bottom line: Monmouth's coaching staff should have Evan Colon's name on the board. At 22 miles away with Division I tools and no other offers on the table, the value proposition doesn't get much cleaner than this.